In Hotline Bae, several people who were taken from the studio audience must each pick one of the That's My Baes. Each member of the That's My Bae is holding a cell phone. Only one of those cell phones has the correct number to call Maine Mendoza. The lucky person who picked the correct cell phone advances to the jackpot round.
In the jackpot round, the player is presented with a row of tablet computers that each contains one number. The player must guess whether the next tablet has a higher than, lower than, or the same number as the previous one. The jackpot round has the same format as the former segment Hi-Lo Todo Panalo.